Account
Don’t have an account? Sign up
Help and preferences
Help
Settings & privacy
Patrick Connor: Great Depression was no match for Canzoneri-Kid Chocolate
Article hero background
Patrick Connor: Great Depression was no match for Canzoneri-Kid Chocolate
Link copied!
1 hour ago
1 hour ago
6 min read
As everyone scattered to pick up what was left of the U.S. economy during the Great Depression, somehow Madison Square Garden not only still operated but hosted weekly fight cards.
That boxing either leaned on established stars or quickly created new ones to thrive during those years should come as no shock. The amount of all-time great fighters emerging from the late 1920s and '30s is truly astounding, however, and the struggling masses of New York City knew many of them well.
Tony Canzoneri and Kid Chocolate not only defined their own era, but fought in ways and with technical abilities that transcend the decades. On November 20, 1931, 95 years ago today, they met in the Garden for the first of two fights and produced what one local writer called “one helluva fight scrap.”
Certain styles and techniques could only be employed during specific eras, or perhaps before the implementation of game-changing rules. The most obvious would be the London Prize Ring Rules allowing for pushing, shoving and some wrestling before the Marquess of Queensberry Rules became the standard. During the 1900s and into the '10s, referees commonly disqualified one or both fighters for refusing to engage, which often meant boxing carefully, now widely recognized as simply part of the game, if not one of the essential core styles and tactics of the sport.
Delivering maximum punishment simply never became an antiquated boxing concept. In the 1800s, fans loved a fighter who got straight to the milling and fought aggressively. More than a century later, only the terms and descriptions are different. Action and knockouts still sell tickets and turn heads.
When Canzoneri was just 14, weighing about 100 pounds and fighting out of the Gayoso Athletic Club in New Orleans, a local newspaper described his style: “When Canzoneri fights fans are certain they will get plenty of action. He is of the boring-in type, and unless his opponent is an unusually good defensive boxer they seldom go far.”
Canzoneri moved to New York City in his teens, and he eventually unified the featherweight title, lost it to André Routis and moved up in weight by the time he was 20, though he remained an offensive powerhouse. He wouldn’t usually knock opponents unconscious so much as completely overwhelm them with volume, not to mention the mathematically impossible angles from which they sailed in. Consistent box office numbers translated to approval, and crowds liked Canzoneri.
Eligio Sardiñas, better known by his fighting name Kid Chocolate, similarly aimed to bewilder his foes and became a box office star. Unlike Canzoneri, whose offense and technique was more textbook or typical of a well-schooled fighter, Chocolate bounced around on his toes, darted in and out on opponents and threw punches with wide calligraphic flourishes. The Cuban flashed smiles to crowds and showed off his gold teeth during fights, like former heavyweight champion Jack Johnson used to, then he happily smoked and drank into the night afterward.
When Chocolate dropped a close decision to Jack “Kid” Berg about one year earlier, his manager Luis “Pincho” Gutiérrez, lost a potent promotional tool: the ability to claim his fighter had never before been defeated. Before 1930 ended, Chocolate lost two more fights, albeit again to top fighters in Fidel LaBarba and Bat Battalino.
It didn’t matter, though, because “The Keed” regularly pulled in five-figure attendance figures. He dressed with impeccable style and spent his money partying, making him a crowd favorite away from the ring, too. But finally in August 1931, Chocolate became Cuba’s first world champion when he captured the junior lightweight title by defeating Benny Bass.
In the three years that it took Chocolate to arrive in the U.S., achieve stardom and win a world title, Canzoneri seized the lightweight and junior welterweight titles. He modified his style to be more precise, less about volume.
The junior divisions struggled for widespread recognition at this stage, though few doubted Canzoneri’s credentials, much less his entertainment value. Chocolate, who rarely hesitated to challenge himself in general, quickly accepted the daunting task of moving up to lightweight for Canzoneri just months after becoming a champion at 130 pounds.
At about 5-foot-4, Canzoneri wasn’t a tall lightweight and during his prime he rarely weighed in over the lightweight limit. Chocolate’s problem was his lanky frame kept him well under 135 pounds even when he was an old, out-of-shape fighter, and Canzoneri still outweighed him by nearly five pounds at the weigh-in. Both of Canzoneri’s titles were allowed to be on the line, and a victory would make Chocolate the first Black lightweight champion since “The Old Master” Joe Gans lost the title in 1908.
Canzoneri served Chocolate a dish of foreshadowing via a left hook just after the opening bell at the Garden. The hook caught Chocolate flush and immediately knocked his slicked-back hair messy, then he roared back to force Canzoneri into a clinch in Round 2.
Another quality that made Chocolate crowd delight was his tendency to hit the canvas and bounce up and recover quickly. In the fourth, Canzoneri connected with a quick punch that sent Chocolate down, and true to form he returned to give the champion all he could handle over the next few rounds, particularly the seventh during which Canzoneri was cut badly over the eye.
At several different points, both fighters appeared to simply disregard defense and tear into one another with abandon, ripping punches with both hands. The 19,000 in attendance cheered even when Canzoneri and Chocolate frequently crashed into each other inside, because most clinches didn’t last long, until the rounds hit the double digits.
Canzoneri rocked The Keed in the 10th, staggering him to the ropes and sending blood from a cut lip flying as he survived the round. The battle wore on both fighters, and Canzoneri quietly acquiesced to being held inside as he attacked the challenger, who was too tired to respond with his offense.
Before Round 13, Chocolate and his corner were issued a stern warning for a slippery vaseline-like substance that had been rubbed on his face, presumably to stem Canzoneri’s offensive tide. Chocolate won Rounds 13 and 14 on determination alone. He managed to freeze the champion in the corner just long enough to make the crowd hold its breath. In true champion form, Canzoneri left nothing in the ring and clearly won the final round.
When announcer Joe Humphreys raised Canzoneri’s hand and revealed a split decision, Chocolate was inconsolable, as he had been following previous decisions that went against him. His in-ring emotional outbursts almost came off performative, even if he truly was moved. Writers described the crowd as split on the verdict, but satisfied by the fight itself. “There’s no ovation column in the record book,” wrote Charles Vackner of the Brooklyn Daily Times.
One scorecard was the difference between Chocolate staying a distraught challenger and becoming an instantaneous three-division world champion. A close decision allowed Chocolate and Gutiérrez to claim their fighter simply couldn’t get a fair shake, though legal trouble awaited him over the next several months.
Canzoneri had a few years of championship stuff left in him, though a veritable brick wall of a welterweight division kept him at 140 pounds and below. That was just fine by Chocolate, who called for a rematch until he got it.
The Garden, which took in almost $85,000 for Canzoneri-Chocolate I, hosted another fight the following Friday.

Column
Junior welterweight
Article thumbnail
Next
Patrick Connor: 1976 vs. 2026, boxing then and now
RELATED ARTICLES
Patrick Connor: 106 Years of Jack Dempsey's Filthy Work
Column
Patrick Connor: 106 Years of Jack Dempsey's Filthy Work
Patrick Connor: Remembering the late George Chuvalo
Column
 Patrick Connor: Remembering the late George Chuvalo
Patrick Connor: The Ring's top 10 greatest living fighters
Column
Patrick Connor: The Ring's top 10 greatest living fighters
RELATED ARTICLES
Patrick Connor: 106 Years of Jack Dempsey's Filthy Work
Column
Patrick Connor: 106 Years of Jack Dempsey's Filthy Work
Patrick Connor: Remembering the late George Chuvalo
Column
 Patrick Connor: Remembering the late George Chuvalo
Patrick Connor: The Ring's top 10 greatest living fighters
Column
Patrick Connor: The Ring's top 10 greatest living fighters
Can you beat Coppinger?

Lock in your fantasy picks on rising stars and title contenders for a shot at $100,000 and exclusive custom boxing merch.

Can you beat Coppinger?
Partners
  • Strategic
    Partners
  • Strategic Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight
    Partners
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Heavyweight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight
    Partners
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Middlewight Partners partner logo
  • Lightweight
    Partners
  • Lightweight Partners partner logo
  • Lightweight Partners partner logo
  • Lightweight Partners partner logo
  • Partners
  • Partners partner logo
  • Partners partner logo
  • Partners partner logo
  • Partners partner logo
  • Promoters
  • Promoters partner logo
  • Promoters partner logo
  • Promoters partner logo
  • Promoters partner logo
  • Promoters partner logo
  • Promoters partner logo